- Overall merit: Advance the paper to the next review round?
- Is it clear what is the problem that the paper addresses?
- Is the problem important and within scope for ATC?
- Is it clear what is the main idea(s) proposed in the paper?
- Does the main idea(s) address the problem the paper wants to solve?
- Does the extended abstract provide the appropriate context in terms of related work?
- Based on the evaluation summary, is the experimental evaluation setup appropriate and does the evaluation support the main claims of the paper?
- What is your expertise on the paper’s main topics?
- Are the selected topics in HotCRP appropriate for the paper’s content?
- Additional comments for the authors (optional).